Skip to content
LumenaryLingua
C1 60 min

Media and rhetoric

How Spanish-language newspapers write, how opinion persuades, and how to spot the slant — with a news report and an op-ed to take apart.

AI-draftedAwaiting review by a Spanish teacher
Vocabulary

The vocabulary of the press

In News and experiences you learned to follow the news; in Reported speech, to report what others said. At C1 the question changes from what does it say? to how is it saying it, and why?

SpanishEnglishNotes
el titularheadline
el antetítulokicker, line above the headline
el subtítulostandfirst, subheadingAlso el sumario.
la entradillalead paragraphSpain; el copete in Argentina; el lead is also used.
la pirámide invertidainverted pyramidMost important facts first.
la portadafront page
la fuentesource
fuentes cercanas asources close to
el comunicadostatement, press release
la rueda de prensapress conferenceSpain; la conferencia de prensa in Latin America.
el desmentidoofficial denialdesmentir, to deny
el editorialeditorialMasculine: the paper's own unsigned opinion.
la editorialpublishing houseFeminine.
la columnacolumnel / la columnista
el artículo de opiniónopinion piece, op-ed
la tribunaguest opinion piece
la crónicareport with the writer's voiceBetween news and literature.
el reportajefeature, in-depth report
la carta al directorletter to the editor
la línea editorialeditorial line
el sesgobiassesgado, biased
el bulohoax, false rumourSpain; elsewhere la noticia falsa.
la desinformacióndisinformation
la verificación de datosfact-checking
presuntamenteallegedlyThe legal word: el presunto autor.
al parecerapparently
el titular sensacionalistaclickbait headline
la fe de erratascorrections notice
Grammar

The grammar of the press

Headlines

Spanish headlines compress, and they have their own conventions (the examples here are invented):

  • The present for past events, for immediacy: El Congreso aprueba la reforma de las pensiones (it did so yesterday).
  • The future for planned events: El metro cerrará tres estaciones en agosto.
  • Missing articles and verbs: Récord de visitantes en el museo de la ciudad. · Detenidos dos sospechosos del robo.
  • A colon for attribution: La ministra de Sanidad: «No habrá recortes».
  • The comma for an omitted verb: El Gobierno, contra la subida de tarifas (= está contra).
  • Only the first word capitalised: Nueva ley de vivienda en Uruguay, never Nueva Ley De Vivienda.

The conditional of rumour

El exministro habría cobrado comisiones does not mean "would have received" but "allegedly received": the paper reports a claim it has not confirmed. This condicional de rumor is extremely common, but many style books advise against it because it lets a paper spread a claim without owning it. Careful journalism prefers to name the source: Según la Fiscalía, el exministro cobró comisiones.

Who did it? Agents and their disappearance

Grammar lets a writer show or hide responsibility, and Spanish has more tools for hiding it than English:

VersionEffect
La policía disolvió la protesta.Agent as subject: responsibility is clear.
La protesta fue disuelta por la policía.Passive: the protest is the topic; the agent is still there.
Se disolvió la protesta.Passive se: no agent at all.
Muere un manifestante durante la protesta.Intransitive verb: the death simply "happens".
Disolución de la protesta.Nominalisation: no agent, no time.

None of these is wrong in itself; all can be honest. But when you read se produjeron incidentes or muere un joven tras la intervención, ask who did what.

Reporting verbs carry a judgement

VerbWhat it suggests about the speaker's words
decir, afirmar, declarar, señalarneutral
asegurar, sostenerthe speaker insists; doubt hangs in the air
alegar, pretenderthe reporter is sceptical
reconocer, admitirthe speaker concedes something unfavourable
denunciarthe speaker accuses
advertir, alertarthe speaker warns
lamentarthe speaker regrets
revelarthe information was hidden

La ministra dijo que no habrá recortes and La ministra aseguró que no habrá recortes report the same words; the second invites you not to believe them.

Grammar

News and opinion

Spanish-language newspapers separate their genres, at least in principle:

GenreWhat it isTypical language
la noticiathe report of a recent eventthird person, past tenses, attributed sources, figures
el reportajean in-depth reportbackground, several voices, description
la crónicaan eyewitness account with stylefirst person allowed, narration, evaluation
la entrevistaquestions and answersdirect speech
el editorialthe paper's own position, unsignednosotros or impersonal, modal verbs (debe)
la columnaa regular signed opinionfirst person, irony, personal voice
la tribunaan occasional signed piece by a guestargumentative
la carta al directora reader's lettershort, direct

Markers of opinion: the first person (creo, a mi juicio); evaluative adjectives (vergonzoso, valiente, inadmisible); modal verbs (el Gobierno debería…); rhetorical questions; irony; exclamations; direct appeals to the reader (¿Y usted?); intensifiers of certainty (sin duda, es evidente que). A news report that contains several of these is no longer quite news.

Grammar

Persuasion, fallacies and bias

Persuasion is not manipulation: a good op-ed persuades with evidence and argument. The problem is the technique that replaces argument. These are the names you will meet in Spanish; the examples are invented.

TechniqueSpanish nameExample
Appeal to emotionapelación a las emociones¿Quién se atreve a decirle a un niño que su biblioteca cierra?
False dilemmafalso dilemaO mantenemos la biblioteca o renunciamos a la cultura.
Ad hominemargumento ad hominemLo propone un concejal que no ha leído un libro en su vida.
Straw manfalacia del hombre de pajaLos que quieren cerrarla creen que leer no sirve para nada.
Slippery slopependiente resbaladizaHoy cierran la biblioteca; mañana, el hospital.
Bandwagonapelación a la mayoríaTodo el mundo sabe que…
Hasty generalisationgeneralización apresuradaMi vecino nunca va: nadie la usa.
Loaded languageléxico valorativoel tijeretazo (the axe) vs el ajuste presupuestario
Euphemismeufemismoreestructuración de plantilla for layoffs
Presuppositionpresuposición¿Por qué sigue el alcalde ocultando las cuentas? (assumes he is hiding them)
Cherry-pickingselección interesada de datosquoting the one figure that suits you

A checklist for detecting bias

  1. Genre: is it news or opinion? Is it labelled honestly?
  2. Sources: who is quoted, who is not? Are sources named (según la Fiscalía) or vague (fuentes cercanas)?
  3. Verbs: dijo or alegó? reconoció or explicó?
  4. Agents: who does what — and where has the agent disappeared?
  5. Words: protesta or disturbios? Ajuste or recorte? Régimen or gobierno?
  6. Numbers: absolute or relative? Compared with what?
  7. What is missing: the other side's best argument, context, dates.
Further reading

Reading: one event, two texts

Both texts were written for this lesson, about a fictional town. First the news report, then a columnist's op-ed on the same decision.

The news report

El Ayuntamiento de Santa Inés cerrará la biblioteca del barrio de La Ribera

La medida, incluida en el presupuesto del próximo año, permitirá ahorrar 180 000 euros anuales, según el consistorio

El pleno municipal de Santa Inés de la Vega aprobó ayer, con 11 votos a favor y 10 en contra, el cierre de la biblioteca del barrio de La Ribera a partir de marzo. Según el concejal de Hacienda, Tomás Ferrer, la medida forma parte de un plan de ajuste que permitirá ahorrar unos 180 000 euros al año. Los fondos se trasladarán a la Biblioteca Central, situada a tres kilómetros. Los grupos de la oposición votaron en contra, y la asociación de vecinos ha convocado una concentración para el próximo sábado. De acuerdo con los datos del propio ayuntamiento, la biblioteca recibió el año pasado unas 40 000 visitas.

Inverted pyramid, past tenses, exact figures, every claim attributed (según, de acuerdo con), neutral verbs, no adjectives of judgement.

The op-ed

La biblioteca no es un lujo

Carmen Oyarzábal

Hay decisiones que retratan a quien las toma. La del Ayuntamiento de Santa Inés, que ayer aprobó por un solo voto cerrar la biblioteca de La Ribera, es una de ellas.

Empecemos por los números, ya que el concejal de Hacienda tanto los aprecia. El cierre ahorrará 180 000 euros al año. La biblioteca recibió 40 000 visitas el año pasado: cuatro euros y medio por visita. ¿Hay algún servicio público más barato?

El concejal asegura que los vecinos podrán usar la Biblioteca Central. Se le olvida mencionar que está a tres kilómetros, que el autobús pasa cada cuarenta minutos y que buena parte de los usuarios de La Ribera son niños y personas mayores.

Quienes defienden el cierre nos dicen que hoy todo está en internet y que el papel es cosa del pasado. Pero una biblioteca no es un almacén de libros: es el único lugar del barrio donde un estudiante sin conexión puede hacer los deberes, donde una mujer recién llegada aprende a rellenar un formulario, donde nadie te pide que consumas para quedarte.

Que nadie se engañe: hoy es la biblioteca; mañana será el centro de salud, y pasado mañana, la escuela. O defendemos los servicios públicos ahora, o renunciaremos a ellos para siempre.

Por cierto, no deja de ser curioso que el concejal Ferrer, tan preocupado por el gasto, no haya pisado una biblioteca en años, según cuentan en el barrio.

Todo el mundo sabe que una ciudad que cierra bibliotecas es una ciudad que renuncia al futuro. El sábado, los vecinos de La Ribera se concentrarán frente al ayuntamiento. Yo estaré allí. ¿Y usted?

Taking it apart

PassageTechniqueVerdict
Hay decisiones que retratan a quien las toma.Evaluative framing in the first lineLegitimate in opinion, but it judges before arguing.
por un solo votoSelection: the news said 11 a 10Accurate, but chosen to suggest weakness.
cuatro euros y medio por visitaArgument from dataSound and checkable (180 000 ÷ 40 000 = 4.5), though visits are not users.
Se le olvida mencionar que…Irony; relevant counter-evidenceFair: distance and bus frequency matter.
Quienes defienden el cierre nos dicen que…Straw manThe council never said this; its argument was cost.
donde…, donde…, donde…Anaphora, concrete examplesThe strongest argument in the piece.
hoy es la biblioteca; mañana…Slippery slopeNo evidence offered.
O defendemos… o renunciaremos…False dilemmaIgnores intermediate options (reduced hours, shared building).
no haya pisado una biblioteca… según cuentanAd hominem plus an unverified sourceIrrelevant to the argument and unconfirmed.
Todo el mundo sabe que…Appeal to the majorityAsserts instead of arguing.
Yo estaré allí. ¿Y usted?Call to action, rhetorical questionTypical and legitimate close for a column.

The verdict is mixed, which is the point: the op-ed contains a good argument (cost per visit, access, what a library does) wrapped in techniques that a careful reader should discount. A fair-minded columnist could make the same case without the last four.

Culture

The Spanish-language press

Every Spanish-speaking country has its newspapers of record, and many are over a century old: El País, El Mundo, ABC and La Vanguardia in Spain; Clarín and La Nación in Argentina; El Universal, Reforma and La Jornada in Mexico; El Tiempo in Colombia; El Mercurio in Chile; El Comercio in Peru. They differ in editorial line, and reading the same story in two of them is the best exercise in detecting bias you can do. Much of the international news in Spanish comes from the agency EFE, the largest Spanish-language news agency.

The language of the press has its own guardians. Major papers publish style books (libros de estilo) that rule on everything from headline capitals to the conditional of rumour, and the Fundéu RAE, set up by EFE and now run with the Real Academia Española, answers journalists' doubts every day. Since the 2010s, fact-checking organisations have grown across the Spanish-speaking world — among them Chequeado in Argentina, Colombiacheck in Colombia, and Maldita.es and Newtral in Spain — and their published methods are a good model of how to verify a claim before sharing it.

Common misconceptionsH

Common misconceptions

Misconception

"News with no adjectives is objective." Bias also lives in the choice of story, the order of facts, the verbs of reporting, the sources quoted and the agent left out. The news report above is careful; even so, putting 11 votos a favor y 10 en contra rather than por un solo voto is itself a choice.

Misconception

"Habría cobrado means 'would have received'." In the press, the conditional often means "reportedly / allegedly". Read it as a warning: the claim is unconfirmed.

Misconception

"La editorial is an editorial." La editorial publishes books; el editorial is the newspaper's opinion piece.

Misconception

"A quoted source is a confirmed fact." Según fuentes cercanas al ministerio tells you someone said it, not that it is true. Ask how many sources, and whether any is named.

Exercises

Practice

Several exercises refer to the news report and the op-ed above; keep them open.

1. Media and rhetoric

Warm-upHuman

Today's paper has the headline El Congreso aprueba la reforma de las pensiones. When did the vote most likely take place?

Choose one

2. Media and rhetoric

CoreHuman

What does the conditional mean in this headline?

El exalcalde habría desviado fondos públicos a una empresa familiar.

Choose one

3. Media and rhetoric

Warm-upHuman

Give the one-word Spanish adverb used in legal and press language for allegedly:

El detenido, ______ implicado en el robo, declaró ayer ante el juez.

4. Media and rhetoric

Warm-upHuman

Complete with the article:

______ editorial de hoy critica con dureza la nueva ley.

(The newspaper's own opinion piece.)

5. Media and rhetoric

CoreHuman

Which verb suggests that the minister admitted something unfavourable?

La ministra ______ que el proyecto lleva un año de retraso.

Choose one

6. Media and rhetoric

CoreHuman

Which technique is this, from the op-ed?

Hoy es la biblioteca; mañana será el centro de salud, y pasado mañana, la escuela.

Choose one

7. Media and rhetoric

CoreHuman

Why is this sentence a falso dilema?

O defendemos los servicios públicos ahora, o renunciaremos a ellos para siempre.

Choose one

8. Media and rhetoric

StretchHuman

Which headline hides who was responsible most completely?

Choose one

9. Media and rhetoric

CoreHuman

Which features mark the op-ed La biblioteca no es un lujo as opinion rather than news? Select all that apply.

Choose all that apply

10. Media and rhetoric

CoreHuman

Complete the classic journalistic formula for an unnamed source:

Según fuentes ______ al ministerio, la ley se votará en marzo.

11. Media and rhetoric

Warm-upHuman

Which genre is an unsigned piece that states the newspaper's own position?

Choose one

Further reading and resources

  • Fundéu RAESet up by the news agency EFE and now run together with the Real Academia Española, it publishes daily recommendations on the language of the media.
  • ChequeadoAn Argentine fact-checking organisation; its explanations of how claims are checked are good advanced reading.
  • Maldita.esA Spanish fact-checking and anti-hoax project.